Assignment: Annotated Bibliography

An annotated bibliography provides specific information about each source you have used. As a researcher, you have become an expert on your topic and have the ability both to explain the content and to assess the usefulness of your sources for those not in the know. Think of your paper as part of a conversation with others interested in the same things you are; the annotated bibliography allows you to tell readers what to check out, what might be worth checking out in some situations, and what might not be worth spending the time on. It’s kind of like providing a list of good movies for your classmates to watch and then going over the list with them, telling them why this movie is better than that one or why one student in your class might like a particular movie better than another student would. You want to give your audience enough information to understand basically what the movies are about and to make an informed decision about where to spend their money based on their interests” (“Annotated Bibliography”).

Essentially, this assignment consists of two elements that will be blended together:

  • A Works Cited page in MLA format that lists all of the research sources you have found and evaluated thus far for your final paper
  • A 3–4 sentence-long mini-evaluation immediately following each of these source’s citation that shows how and why this source will be useful to your final project (or not). This evaluation should include your interpretation of the source’s thesis or overall focus.

An MLA example, using the source for the above quote:

“Annotated Bibliography.” Handouts and Links. The Writing Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2007. Web. 12 Feb. 2010. This source is a handout made available by a reputable university’s writing center, and describes with great detail and examples what an annotated bibliography is and what purpose it serves. It contains an extensive list of works consulted that could lead me toward additional sources as needed.

Student Samples (MLA format)

Sample A.B. #1 (Google Doc link)

Sample A.B. #2 (Google Doc link)

Assignment Requirements

Your final Annotated Bibliography will have 12 sources listed.  Of those,

  • at least 5 will be academic journal article sources, retrieved from the school or a public library
  • at least 2 will be book-length, either physical books or ebooks from the Library or online
  • at least 1 will be an online media source, such as a YouTube video, podcast, or interactive presentation
  • at least 2 sources (of any of the above formats) must contain elements that DISAGREE with your own position on the matter
  • The remaining 4 sources will be “wild card” slots—anything you want to include.

The remaining sources may fall into whichever category you choose. You may single-space both the citations and evaluations to make it more reader-friendly. Entries should be organized in alphabetical order. We are using MLA formatting, for the Bibliography as well as the final Research Essay.

Remember, this is just an assignment to demonstrate the range of research you’ll be doing for your final essay.  You won’t be expected to use all of these sources in your final paper, and if you find more after you’ve turned this in, you can use those instead.  The Annotated Bibliography is a snapshot of where you are in the research process at this particular point in time.

You’re also more than welcome to recycle sources you’ve used in earlier assignments.

Grading Rubric

Annotated Bibliography Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Citations
Citations exactly follow MLA guidelines for bibliographic entries. They will need few to no changes in order to be ready for use in the final research essay.

40 pts

Citations closely follow MLA guidelines. They will need some changes before they are ready for the final research essay.

33 pts

Citations follow MLA guidelines, but are missing key elements and/or have elements out of order. They will need editing before they are ready for the final research essay.

26 pts

Citations do not follow MLA guidelines at all, though they do have some sense of formatting. They will need to be heavily edited before they are ready for the final research essay.

19 pts

Citations are incomplete or entirely missing.

0 pts

40 pts
Annotation Contents
Paragraphs following citations are richly detailed, giving a clear summary of the source along with brief but thorough explanations regarding the source’s validity and usefulness to your research goals. Expertly edited and proofread content.

40 pts

Paragraphs following citations are detailed, giving a summary of the source along with some explanations regarding the source’s validity and usefulness to your research goals. Edited and proofread content, perhaps with some minor errors.

33 pts

Paragraphs following citations are detailed but may be missing one of the following: summary/ validity/ usefulness. Edited content, though containing multiple errors.

26 pts

Paragraphs following citations are extremely brief and don’t convey how the sources fit in with your research project. No sense of editing or proofreading before submission; errors may lead to misunderstanding or confusion.

19 pts

Paragraphs are extremely short or nonexistant.

0 pts

40 pts
Required Number & Kinds of Sources
Bibliography contains at least 12 sources; of these at least 5 are from the library, at least 2 are book-length; at least 1 is an online media source; at least 2 contain opinions that disagree with your own.

10 pts

Bibliography contains at least 12 sources; of these at least 5 are from the library, at least 2 are book-length; at least 1 is an online media source. If there are two that contain opinions contradictory to your own, they are not clearly marked in the bibliography and so not immediately obvious to your reader.

7 pts

Bibliography contains at least 12 sources; may be missing 1 or 2 of the required kinds of sources from the assignment.

5 pts

Bibliography contains at least 8 sources and/or may be missing 2-3 specific kinds of sources from the assignment.

2 pts

Bibliography contains fewer than 8 sources.

0 pts

10 pts
Formatting
Document is formatted exactly by MLA guidelines. Citations are alphabetized and use hanging indent.

10 pts

Document is formatted by MLA guidelines, perhaps with one or two minor errors. Citations are alphabetized and use hanging indent.

7 pts

Document is formatted by MLA guidelines, though with errors. Citations may not be alphabetized, and/or do use hanging indent.

5 pts

Document is not formatted using MLA guidelines. Citations are not alphabetized, and do use hanging indent.

2 pts

No specific page formatting is used at all.

0 pts

10 pts
Total Points: 100